College football overtime throws out the kickoff, the clock and the tie. When a game is level after four quarters, the teams alternate possessions starting at the opponent’s 25-yard line: each team gets the ball there, plays a normal series, and tries to outscore the other in that round. In the first overtime, touchdowns are followed by a normal try (kick or two-point attempt); from the second overtime, a touchdown must be followed by a two-point attempt; and from the third overtime onward there are no full possessions at all — the game becomes alternating two-point tries from the 3-yard line until one team converts and the other doesn’t. There is no game clock (only the play clock) and no possibility of a tie: the format, in place in evolving forms since 1996, guarantees a winner. Here is how it works, step by step, and how it differs from the NFL system in our NFL overtime guide.
Key Takeaways
- College overtime = alternating possessions from the defense’s 25-yard line, one possession per team per period, until a round ends unequal.
- No kickoffs, no game clock, no ties. The coin-toss winner usually chooses to play defense first.
- First overtime: normal try after a touchdown (kick allowed). Second overtime: two-point attempt mandatory after a touchdown.
- Third overtime onward: no possessions — teams alternate single two-point conversion plays from the 3-yard line.
- A defense can score in overtime (a turnover returned for a touchdown), which can end the game immediately.
- The NFL’s system is entirely different: timed periods, kickoffs, and regular-season ties — college OT guarantees a winner every time.
Step by step: how a college overtime unfolds
The coin toss. Captains meet again. The toss winner chooses either to start on offense or defense, or which end of the field to use (possessions in a period are played at the same end, chosen for wind or crowd reasons). Almost every winner chooses defense first: in a format where each side gets the same possession, knowing exactly what you need — a field goal, a touchdown, a touchdown and two — is worth more than the ball.
The possession. The offense takes over at the defense’s 25-yard line, first-and-10, and plays ordinary football under ordinary rules: it can earn first downs, kick a field goal on any down, or lose the ball on downs, a fumble or an interception. Two college-specific notes: the defense can score — intercept and return it the length of the field, and the game ends on the spot if it breaks the tie of the round — and a change of possession ends the series instantly: unlike in regulation play, the defense cannot turn a takeaway into a possession of its own starting from the recovery spot; the return counts only if it reaches the end zone. Each team has one timeout per overtime period.
Matching and winning. If the first offense scores a field goal, the second offense wins with a touchdown, ties with a field goal (sending the game to the next period), and loses with anything less. Rounds repeat — with teams swapping who plays offense first each period — until a round ends with the scores unequal. Only then is there a winner, which is why final scores in long overtimes can look like basketball results.
The escalation ladder (the 2021 rules)
The format’s modern shape is a deliberate anti-marathon device, rebuilt after the famous seven-overtime game in November 2018 in which Texas A&M beat LSU 74–72 — a game that lasted nearly five hours, rewrote record books for scoring, and convinced rulemakers that possessions from the 25, repeated indefinitely, produced statistics and fatigue nobody wanted. The current ladder:
- First overtime: standard possessions from the 25; after a touchdown, the scoring team may kick the extra point or go for two.
- Second overtime: standard possessions; after a touchdown, the team must attempt a two-point conversion — no kicks.
- Third overtime and beyond: possessions vanish. Each “period” is a single two-point attempt from the 3-yard line for each team, alternating until one converts and the other fails. (This two-point shootout previously began in the fifth overtime under the 2019 revision; the 2021 rules moved it to the third.)
The design logic is transparent: every round raises the variance and the scoring probability per play, compressing endings toward a conclusion while keeping the first overtime recognizably football.
College OT vs. NFL OT: the differences that matter
- Start of play: college — possessions at the opponent’s 25, no kickoff. NFL — a kickoff and normal field position.
- Clock: college — no game clock at all, only the play clock. NFL — a 10-minute period in the regular season, 15-minute periods in the playoffs.
- Possessions: college — guaranteed equal and alternating by design. NFL — both teams are guaranteed a possession under the current rules, but field position is earned, not granted.
- Ties: college — impossible; a winner is required. NFL — possible in the regular season when the period expires level.
- Late rounds: college — a two-point shootout from the third overtime. NFL — additional full periods in the playoffs until someone wins.
- Try rules: college — two-point attempts become mandatory from the second overtime. NFL — standard try rules throughout.
The philosophical split is the story: the NFL treats overtime as a (shortened) continuation of the game, with field position, punting and clock management intact. College treats it as a tiebreaker procedure — closer to a penalty shootout with full playbooks — deliberately isolating the scoring contest from special teams and field position. Each has its critics: the NFL’s ties and coin-flip anxieties against college’s artificial 25-yard starts and shootout endings that can decide a championship race on two-point plays. Our two-point conversion explainer covers the play that now ends every long college game.
Strategy notes fans argue about
Playing defense first is orthodoxy because of information, but the second team’s advantage is partly offset by fourth-down pressure: the first offense, not knowing what it needs, plays conservatively (the field goal on fourth-and-short), while the response can be calibrated. In the two-point shootout rounds, play-calling inverts: offenses choose their single best two-point play repeatedly from a shrinking menu, and defenses that have seen the same concept twice begin jumping it — one reason shootouts rarely extend beyond a few rounds. And field-goal kickers matter enormously in round one and then vanish from the format entirely after the second period, the oddest career arc in any rulebook.
College football overtime FAQ
When did college football adopt overtime?
The current alternating-possessions format became standard for Division I in 1996. Before that, regular-season games could end in ties.
Can a college football game end in a tie?
No. Overtime periods repeat — escalating to two-point shootouts from the third period — until one team wins.
Where does the ball start in college overtime?
At the opponent’s 25-yard line for each possession in the first two overtime periods. From the third period, teams run two-point attempts from the 3-yard line.
Why do teams choose defense first?
Information: the team on offense second knows exactly what result it needs (field goal to extend, touchdown to win) and can use all four downs accordingly.
Can the defense score in college overtime?
Yes. A turnover returned for a touchdown by the defense counts and, if it decides the round, ends the game immediately.
How is college overtime different from the NFL’s?
College starts possessions at the 25 with no clock and no ties; the NFL kicks off, plays timed periods, guarantees both teams a possession, and allows regular-season ties.
Related reading
Compare the pro system in our NFL overtime guide, master the decisive play in our two-point conversion explainer, and follow overtime thrillers on our College Football scores page and the College Football hub.
Corrections: if you spot an error in this guide, tell us through our Corrections Policy page and we will check it against official sources.