The Heisman Trophy, awarded every December since 1935, goes to the player voted the most outstanding in college football. It is not chosen by the NCAA and there are no official statistical criteria: the trophy is decided by 928 electors — 870 media members divided equally among six geographic regions (145 each), every living former Heisman winner, and one collective fan vote. Each voter names three players; a first-place vote is worth three points, second two, third one, and the highest points total wins. Ballots close in early December, immediately after conference championship weekend and before any bowl game is played, which makes the Heisman a regular-season award in practice even though its motto is the whole season. The winner is announced at a televised ceremony in New York City, and the trophy itself — a bronze running back executing a stiff-arm — has become the most recognizable individual prize in American team sports. This guide covers the voting system, the trophy’s history, and the honest pattern of what the electorate actually rewards.
Key Takeaways
- 928 electors pick the winner: 870 regional media voters, all living past winners, and one aggregated fan vote.
- Ballots rank three players (3-2-1 points). Voting closes right after conference championship weekend — bowls and the playoff do not count.
- The award dates to 1935 (Jay Berwanger) and was renamed for coach John Heisman in 1936; the Heisman Trust runs it today.
- Ohio State’s Archie Griffin (1974, 1975) is the only two-time winner. Michigan’s Charles Woodson (1997) is the only primarily defensive winner.
- Quarterbacks dominate the modern era — roughly four of every five recent winners — because the electorate rewards visible production on winning teams.
- Reggie Bush’s forfeited 2005 trophy was formally restored by the Trust in 2024, after the NIL era changed the rules landscape.
Who votes, and how the points work
The electorate is designed for geographic balance. The country is divided into six regions — Far West, Mid-Atlantic, Midwest, Northeast, South and Southwest — and each receives exactly 145 media votes, so no region’s press corps can swamp another’s. Layered on top are the votes of every living Heisman winner (57 voters in recent counts — the number moves year to year as winners pass away and are added) and a single fan vote, determined by an official online fan poll and cast as one ballot. Total: 928 ballots.
Each ballot lists three players in order. Points are awarded 3 for first, 2 for second, 1 for third, and the player with the highest total wins — meaning the award can go to a player who wasn’t the plurality first-place choice if he appears on more ballots overall, though in most years the winner leads both counts. The Heisman Trust, the charitable organization that has administered the award since the original Downtown Athletic Club’s era ended, invites the top vote-getters — typically three to five players — to New York as finalists for the ceremony, held on the Saturday after championship weekend. Secrecy around totals is tight; the Trust announces the winner’s points and, in recent years, the full top-10 voting, which has become a genre of second-day analysis in itself.
A short history of the trophy
The Downtown Athletic Club of New York created the award in 1935 as its DAC Trophy for the best player east of the Mississippi — an eligibility scope widened immediately after the first presentation to Jay Berwanger of the University of Chicago. When the club’s legendary athletic director John Heisman — the coach and innovator for whom the trophy is now named — died in October 1936, the award was renamed in his honor; Yale’s Larry Kelley was the first winner of the “Heisman Trophy” proper. The bronze statue itself was sculpted by Frank Eliscu and modeled on New York University running back Ed Smith; its stiff-arm pose was chosen to symbolize an athlete fighting for every yard.
The winner’s list traces the sport’s eras: the single-wing backs of the 1930s and 40s, the running-back decades that followed (with Notre Dame, Ohio State, USC and Oklahoma building dynasties partly on Heisman winners), the first sophomore winner (there were none until the 2000s — Tim Tebow in 2007), the first freshman (redshirt freshman Johnny Manziel in 2012, followed a year later by redshirt freshman Jameis Winston), and the quarterback avalanche of the 21st century. Two defensive landmarks stand out: no primarily defensive player won until Charles Woodson’s 1997 season — and Woodson also returned punts and moonlighted at receiver, which tells you what a pure defender would need — and no true freshman has ever won. When the Downtown Athletic Club went bankrupt in 2002, administration passed fully to the Heisman Trust, which runs the award, the ceremony and the trophy’s licensing today.
The strangest chapter is Reggie Bush. USC’s 2005 winner forfeited his trophy in 2010 after an NCAA investigation found he had received impermissible benefits; USC returned its copy and the award stood officially vacant. In April 2024, citing the transformed landscape of college athlete compensation (our NIL guide covers the new rules), the Trust formally restored Bush’s Heisman and returned his trophy — a closing of the books on the amateurism era by the very institution built to honor it.
What the trophy actually rewards
The official instruction to voters is simply to choose the most outstanding player, with no criteria attached. Eighty-nine electorates of behavior reveal the real formula:
Production that voters can see. Counting stats on television drive ballots. Quarterbacks of high-scoring offenses accumulate the counting stats and the highlights simultaneously, which is why the modern award is functionally a quarterback prize with occasional rebellions. Winning. Losing teams almost never produce winners; voters treat team success as a filter, and the finalist pool is drawn overwhelmingly from playoff contenders (the machinery that selects those is covered in our playoff guide). The late-season moment. Because ballots close after championship weekend, the last impression is enormous: conference-title-game performances and one signature November play — the “Heisman moment” — have decided more close races than September statistics ever did. Position physics. Running backs won for decades when offenses ran through them; as the sport spread out, the award followed the ball to quarterbacks. Wide receivers (Desmond Howard in 1991, DeVonta Smith in 2020) and the rare two-way star (Woodson; Travis Hunter’s two-way 2024 win) can break through, but they must produce undeniable, highlight-dense seasons to overcome the quarterback default.
What it does not reward: professional projection (NFL success correlates loosely at best — the trophy’s bust list is famous), full-time defenders (Michigan’s Aidan Hutchinson finished second in 2021, still the modern ceiling for a defensive player), offensive linemen at all, and anything that happens in a bowl game — the votes are already counted. It is, honestly assessed, an award for the most visible excellent player on a winning team in the regular season — and accepting that definition is the easiest way to predict it.
How the race unfolds each season
Oddsmaker-free and honest, the calendar is: preseason watch lists built on returning stars (the AP and conference polls described in our rankings guide shape the starting narrative); a September-October sorting in which contenders rise and fall weekly on televised performances; November elimination Saturdays; and the decisive championship weekend, after which ballots are cast within days. Schools formally campaign — websites, mailers to voters, statistical packets — with diminishing subtlety and, historically, real effect at the margins of close races.
Heisman Trophy FAQ
How many people vote for the Heisman?
928 electors: 870 media members (145 in each of six regions), every living former winner, and one aggregated fan vote.
When is the Heisman decided?
Voting closes in early December, right after conference championship weekend, and the winner is announced at a ceremony in New York the following Saturday. Bowl games and the playoff are not considered.
Has anyone won the Heisman twice?
Only Archie Griffin of Ohio State, in 1974 and 1975.
Has a defensive player ever won?
Michigan’s Charles Woodson (1997) is the only primarily defensive winner — he also returned punts and played some receiver. No pure defender or offensive lineman has won.
Can a freshman win the Heisman?
Redshirt freshmen have: Johnny Manziel (2012) and Jameis Winston (2013). No true freshman has won it.
Did Reggie Bush get his Heisman back?
Yes. Bush forfeited the 2005 award in 2010 amid an NCAA benefits investigation, and the Heisman Trust formally restored it in 2024 following the sport’s rule changes on athlete compensation.
Related reading
Follow the season-long race through our rankings explainer and playoff guide, and track contenders weekly on our College Football hub and scores page.
Corrections: if you spot an error in this guide, tell us through our Corrections Policy page and we will check it against official sources.