NFL free agency is the annual open market that begins when the new league year starts in mid-March. A player whose contract has expired becomes one of three kinds of free agent, sorted by experience: an unrestricted free agent (four or more accrued seasons) may sign anywhere; a restricted free agent (three accrued seasons) can negotiate elsewhere, but his old team holds matching rights and may be owed a draft pick; an exclusive-rights free agent (fewer than three) can only re-sign with his own team if it offers him a minimum contract. Two days before the market officially opens, the “legal tampering” window lets teams negotiate with agents — which is why the biggest deals are reported minutes after the market supposedly starts.
This guide explains the tiers, the restricted free agent tender system, the tampering window’s strange etiquette, and the compensatory-pick formula that quietly shapes who gets paid.
Key Takeaways
- Free agency opens at the start of the league year in mid-March; the two-day legal tampering window precedes it.
- Status is set by accrued seasons: 4+ = unrestricted, 3 = restricted, under 3 = exclusive-rights.
- Restricted free agents are tendered at levels tied to draft-pick compensation (first-round, second-round, or right-of-first-refusal).
- A signed offer sheet gives the original team five days to match; if it declines, the compensation pick transfers.
- Compensatory picks reward teams that lose more free agents than they gain — a formula that makes some teams deliberately quiet in March.
- The franchise tag (see our salary cap guide) can remove one star per team from the market entirely.
The three tiers, sorted by accrued seasons
An accrued season is a year in which a player was on full-pay status (active roster, injured reserve, or PUP) for at least six regular-season games. Accrued seasons are the league’s seniority currency, and free agency is where they cash in:
- Unrestricted free agents (UFA): four or more accrued seasons and an expired contract. Completely free: no matching rights, no compensation owed to the old team (beyond the compensatory-pick formula below). Almost every headline signing is a UFA.
- Restricted free agents (RFA): exactly three accrued seasons. The original team can extend a one-year tender offer at one of three levels, and the level determines what it receives if the player signs elsewhere: a first-round pick, a second-round pick, or — at the lowest level — merely the right to match, plus a pick in the round the player was originally drafted (which is nothing if he was undrafted).
- Exclusive-rights free agents (ERFA): fewer than three accrued seasons. If the team tenders a minimum-salary contract, the player cannot negotiate with anyone else. If the team declines to tender, he becomes unrestricted — the mechanism behind most “the team non-tendered him” transaction-wire lines.
Players with expired contracts who don’t fit neatly — veterans released early, for instance — are free immediately upon release (a “street free agent”), which is why mid-season signings and camp cuts don’t wait for March.
Offer sheets: the RFA market’s chess match
An RFA who receives a tender may negotiate with other teams and sign an offer sheet — a binding contract offer. His original team then has five days to match it exactly, keeping the player on those terms; if it declines, the player joins his new team and the tender-level draft pick changes hands. Offer sheets are rare by design: the compensation prices most RFAs out of the market, and new teams historically loaded offer sheets with “poison pills” (clauses the original team couldn’t match) until the practice was banned in the 2011 collective bargaining agreement. When an RFA plays out the season on his one-year tender, he reaches unrestricted free agency the following March — the path most young starters take to their first real payday.
The ERFA and RFA years are also where the fifth-year option and the franchise tag enter for premium players — the whole apparatus of team control, sequenced across a career, is the subject of our salary cap guide (/nfl-salary-cap-explained-dead-money-restructures-and-the-franchise-tag/).
The legal tampering window
Officially, no team may negotiate with another team’s pending free agent until the league year begins. Unofficially, the Combine in late February was for years an open bazaar of exactly that. The league’s compromise, formalized in 2013, is the legal tampering window — officially the “negotiating period”: beginning two days before the new league year (typically Monday at noon Eastern), clubs may contact the certified agents of pending unrestricted free agents and negotiate contract terms in full.
The etiquette is precise: deals may be agreed in principle and widely reported (“expected to sign a four-year deal”), but no contract can be signed, no player can visit a facility, and no direct contact with the player himself is allowed until 4 p.m. Eastern on the Wednesday the league year opens. Deals occasionally collapse in the gap — a physical flag, a better offer, cold feet on either side — which is why careful writers say “agreed to terms” until the ink exists. Every March, the tampering window produces the same illusion: a market that appears to explode at 4 p.m. Wednesday actually detonated on Monday, in two days of entirely legal tampering.
The market’s rhythm — and the comp-pick shadow
Free agency proceeds in waves: a first-day frenzy for premium UFAs (paid, routinely, like the stars they are replacing), a second wave of starters at market-corrected prices, and a long bargain tail into training camp — where one-year “prove it” deals cluster. The structures come from the cap machinery in our salary cap guide: signing bonuses prorated over up to five years, void years, back-loaded salaries. A “four-year, $80 million” signing is best read as its guarantees, always.
Hanging over every signing is the compensatory pick formula: teams that lose more or better free agents than they sign receive extra draft picks (at the ends of rounds three through seven) in the following year’s draft, calculated from the departed players’ contracts, playing time and honors. The formula explains behavior fans find baffling — a contending team letting a good starter walk without signing a replacement, or signing a released “street” free agent (who doesn’t count in the formula) instead of an identical UFA. In effect, the league pays disciplined teams in draft capital for their restraint, and the smartest front offices treat March as two markets: the players, and the picks their departures create. It’s also why trades for expiring contracts (see our trades guide (/how-nfl-trades-work-deadlines-draft-pick-values-and-why-deals-fall-through/)) get done: a contender renting a star for half a season may recoup a comp pick when he leaves.
NFL free agency FAQ
When does NFL free agency start?
At the start of the new league year, in mid-March (4 p.m. Eastern). The two-day legal tampering window opens the preceding Monday at noon Eastern.
What is the difference between a UFA and an RFA?
An unrestricted free agent (4+ accrued seasons) can sign anywhere with no strings. A restricted free agent (3 seasons) is tendered by his team, which can match any offer sheet and may receive a draft pick if he leaves.
What is an accrued season?
A season with at least six regular-season games on full-pay status (active roster, IR, or PUP). Accrued seasons determine free-agent status and minimum salaries.
What is an offer sheet?
A contract an RFA signs with a new team. His original team has five days to match it exactly or lose him and collect the tender-level draft pick.
What are compensatory picks?
Extra draft picks (rounds 3–7) awarded to teams whose free-agent losses outweigh their signings under a league formula based on contracts, playing time and honors.
Can a team stop its best player from leaving?
Once per year, yes — the franchise tag keeps one pending free agent on a one-year, fully guaranteed deal at a top-of-position price. See our salary cap guide for how tags work.
Related reading
Free agency is one leg of the roster-building triangle — complete it with our guides to the salary cap (/nfl-salary-cap-explained-dead-money-restructures-and-the-franchise-tag/), NFL trades (/how-nfl-trades-work-deadlines-draft-pick-values-and-why-deals-fall-through/) and the NFL draft (/how-the-nfl-draft-works-order-picks-trades-and-the-rookie-wage-scale/), and follow every signing on our NFL hub (/nfl/).
Corrections: if you spot an error in this guide, tell us through our Corrections Policy (/corrections-policy/) page and we will check it against official sources.